Jump to ContentJump to Main Navigation
Justinian's Digest: Character and Compilation$

Tony Honoré

Print publication date: 2010

Print ISBN-13: 9780199593309

Published to Oxford Scholarship Online: May 2011

DOI: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199593309.001.0001

Show Summary Details
Page of

PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2017. All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the licence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of a monograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: null; date: 25 February 2017

(p.151) Addendum A Bluhme-Krüger Ordo Librorum Iuris Veteris in Compilandis Digestis Observatus (Updated in the Light of Modern Scholarship)

(p.151) Addendum A Bluhme-Krüger Ordo Librorum Iuris Veteris in Compilandis Digestis Observatus (Updated in the Light of Modern Scholarship)

Source:
Justinian's Digest: Character and Compilation
Publisher:
Oxford University Press

In this list of the order in which the works read in compiling the Digest were perused, commonly known as the BK Ordo, Krüger’s numbering of the works is retained in the interests of convenience. Authors’ names are given in the nominative case.

  • A = group based on authorship

  • S = group based on subject-matter

  • G = group based on literary genre

  • N = work added or inserted to achieve numerical balance

  • Sab. = Sabinian mass

  • Ed. = edictal mass

  • Pap. = Papinian mass

  • App. = Appendix

  • ID = mass indeterminate

  • IA = Index auctorum veterum

  • H = according to Honoré

  • M = according to Mantovani

  • O = according to Osler

Sabinian mass

  1. (i) ad Sabinum group. S.

    1. 1. Ulpianus 51 ad Sabinum

    2. 2. Pomponius 36 ad Sabinum

    3. 3. Paulus 16 ad Sabinum (p.152)

  2. (ii) middle edictal commentaries group. S.

    1. 4. Ulpianus 81 ad edictum lib. 26-51 init.

    2. 5. Paulus 78 ad edictum lib. 28-48 init.

    3. 6. Paulus 23 brevium lib. 6-8

    4. 7. Gaius 30 ad edictum provinciale lib. 9-188. Gaius ad edictum urbanum 2 lib. de testamentis

    5. 9. Gaius ad edictum urbanum 3 lib. de legatis

  3. (iii) Ulpian group. A.

    1. 10. Ulpianus 10 disputationum

    2. 11. Ulpianus 10 de omnibus tribunalibus Unattached

    3. 12. Ulpianus 6 opinionum

    4. 13. Ulpianus 6 de censibus (position in mass doubted by M)

  4. (iv) Julian group. A.

    1. 14. Iulianus 90 digestorum

    2. 15. Alfenus Varus 7 dig. ( 40 dig. IA.)

    3. 16. Paulus 8 epitomatorum Alfeni digestorum

    4. 17. Iulianus de ambiguitatibus

    5. 18. Iulianus 4 ad Urseium Ferocem

    6. 19. Iulianus 6 ex Minicio

    7. 20. Africanus 9 quaestionum

  5. (v) institutions group. G.

    1. 21. Florentinus 12 institutionum

    2. 22. Marcianus 16 institutionum

    3. 23. Ulpianus 2 institutionum

    4. 24. Gaius 3 rerum cottidianum ( 7 rer. cott. IA.)

    5. 25. Gaius 4 institutionum

    6. 26. Callistratus 3 institutionum

    7. 27. Paulus 2 institutionum

  6. (vi) adultery group. S.

    1. 28. Ulpianus 5 de adulteriis

    2. 29. Papinianus 2 de adulteriis

    3. 30. Papinianus 1 de adulteriis

    4. 31. Paulus 3 de adulteriis

      Unattached

    5. 32. Ulpianus 1 de sponsalibus (ID, M; Sab., H)

    6. 33. Paulus 1 de dotis repetitione

    7. 34. Paulus 1 de adsignatione libertorum

    8. 35. Paulus 1 de iure patronatus (ID, M; Sab., H) (p.153)

  7. (vii) regulae group. G.

    1. 36. Neratius 15 regularum

    2. 37. Ulpianus 7 regularum

    3. 38. Scaevola 4 regularum

    4. 39. Paulus 1 regularum

    5. 40. Marcianus 5 regularum lib. 1-2

    6. 41. Ulpianus 2 responsorum

    7. 42. Marcianus 5 regularum lib. 3-4

    8. 43. Paulus 7 regularum

    9. 44. Marcianus 5 regularum lib. 5

    10. 45. Pomponius 1 regularum

    11. 46. Ulpianus 1 regularum

    12. 46 bis. (from BK 59) ? Marcellus 1 responsorum (repositioned,   M; N, H)

      Unattached

    13. 47. Ulpianus 10 de officio proconsulis

    14. 48. Paulus 1 ad SC Silanianum (ID, M; Sab., H)

    15. 49. Paulus 1 de portionibus quae liberis damnatorum conceduntur

    16. 50. Paulus 2 ad legem Iuniam

    17. 51. Paulus 1 de conceptione formularum

  8. (viii) iudicia publica group. S.

    1. 52. Macer 2 publicorum iudiciorum

    2. 53. Venuleius 3 de iudiciis publicis

    3. 54. Paulus 1 de iudiciis publicis

    4. 55. Marcianus 2 de iudiciis publicis

    5. 56. Maecianus 14 de iudiciis publicis

  9. (ix) formula hypothecaria group. S.

    1. 57. Marcianus 1 ad formulam hypothecariam

    2. 58. Gaius 1 de formula hypothecaria

      Unattached

    3. 59. Marcellus 1 responsorum (to BK 46 bis)

    4. 60. Neratius 7 membranarum

    5. 61. Macer 2 de officio praesidis

    6. 62. Arcadius Charisius 1 de testibus

    7. 63. Marcianus 1 de delatoribus

  10. (x) appeals group. S.

    1. 64. Ulpianus 4 de appellationibus

    2. 65. Macer 2 de appellationibus (p.154)

    3. 66. Marcianus 2 de appellationibus

    4. 67. Paulus 1 de appellationibus

      Unattached

    5. 68. Rutilius 1 ad legem Falcidiam

    6. 69. Paulus 1 ad legem Fufiam Caniniam

  11. (xi) lex Aelia Sentia group. S.

    1. 70. Paulus 3 ad legem Aeliam Sentiam

    2. 71. Ulpianus 4 ad legem Aeliam Sentiam

      Unattached

    3. 72. Paulus 1 de libertatibus dandis

    4. 73. Paulus 1 de liberali causa

    5. 74. Paulus 1 de secundis tabulis

    6. 75. Paulus 1 de iure codicillorum

    7. 76. Paulus 1 de centumviralibus iudiciis

    8. 77. Paulus 1 de adulteriis

    9. 78. Paulus 1 de senatusconsultis (ID, M; S or P, H)

    10. 79. Paulus 1 ad SC Velleianum (ID, M; S or P, H)

    11. 80. Paulus 1 de intercessionbus feminarum (ID, M; S or P, H)

    12. 81. Paulus 1 ad orationem divi Antonini et Commodi

    13. 82. Paulus 1 de excusationibus tutelarum (ID, M; S or P, H)

    14. 83. Paulus 1 ad orationem divi Severi

    15. 84. Paulus 1 de variis lectionibus

    16. 85. Ulpianus 1 pandectarum

    17. 86. Macer 2 de re militari

    18. 87. Paulus 1 de poenis militum

    19. 88. Ulpianus 1 de officio curatoris reipublicae

    20. 89. Ulpianus 1 de officio consularium

    21. 90. Paulus 2 de officio consulis

    22. 91. Venuleius Saturninus 4 de officio proconsulis

    23. 92. Claudius Saturninus 1 de poenis paganorum

    24. 93. Volusius Macianus 1 ex lege Rhodia (ID, M)

      (xi bis ?) Labeo posteriora group probably formed from late arrivals. S.

    25. 93 bis. (from BK 265). Labeo 10 posteriorum a Iavoleno epitomatarum lib. 1-2 (S, M, O; for later books see BK 265)

    26. 94. Iavolenus 10 ex posterioribus Labeonis lib. 1-2 (S, M, O; for later books see BK 265 bis)

(p.155)

Papinian mass

  1. (xii) Papinian group. A.

    1. 180. Papinianus 37 quaestionum

    2. 181. Papinianus 19 responsorum

    3. 182. Papinianus 2 definitionum

  2. (xiii) quaestiones group. G.

    1. 183. Paulus 26 quaestionum

    2. 184. Scaevola 20 quaestionum

    3. 185. Callistratus 2 quaestionum

  3. (xiv) responsa group. G.

    1. 186. Paulus 23 responsorum lib. 1-7

    2. 187. Scaevola 6 responsorum lib. 1

    3. 188. Paulus 23 responsorum lib. 8-15

    4. 189. Scaevola 6 responsorum lib. 2-4

    5. 190. Paulus 23 responsorum lib. 16-19

    6. 191. Scaevola 6 responsorum lib. 5

    7. 192. Paulus 23 responsorum lib. 20-23

    8. 193. Scaevola 6 responsorum lib. 6

  4. (xv) fideicommissa group. S.

    1. 195. Ulpianus 6 fideicommissorum lib. 1-4

    2. 194. Valens 7 fideicommissorum lib. 1-4

    3. 196. Maecianus 16 fideicommissorum lib. 1-8

    4. 197. Gaius 2 fideicommissorum

    5. 198. Paulus 3 fideicommissorum lib. 1-2

    6. 199. Pomponius 5 fideicommissorum lib. 1-2

    7. 203. Ulpianus 6 fideicommissorum lib. 5-6

    8. 200. Maecianus 16 fideicommisssorum lib. 9-16

    9. 201. Valens 7 fideicommissorum lib. 5-7

    10. 202. Pomponius 5 fideicommissorum lib. 3-5

    11. 204. Paulus 3 fideicommissorum lib. 3.

  5. (xvi) sententiae/iuris epitomae group. G.

    1. 205. Paulus 5 sententiarum lib. 1 init.

    2. 206. Hermogenianus 6 iuris epitomarum lib. 1

    3. 207. Paulus 5 sententiarum lib.1 fin.- 2

    4. 208. Hermogenianus 6 iuris epitomarum lib. 2

    5. 209. Paulus 5 sententiarum lib. 3

    6. 210. Hermogenianus 6 iuris epitomarum lib. 3 (p.156)

    7. 211. Paulus 5 sententiarum lib. 4

    8. 212. Hermogenianus 6 iuris epitomarum lib. 4

    9. 213. Paulus 5 sententiarum lib. 5

    10. 214. Hermogenianus 6 iuris epitomarum lib. 5-6

      Unattached

    11. 215. Gaius 1 de casibus

    12. 216. Venuleius Saturninus 19 stipulationum

  6. (xvii) Neratius responsa group. S.

    1. 217. Neratius 3 responsorum

    2. 218. Paulus 4 ad Neratium

  7. (xviii) Tryphoninus group. A.

    219. Tryphoninus 21 disputationum lib. 1-12

    220. Paulus 3 manualium

    221. Tryphoninus 21 disputationum lib. 13-21

    222. Paulus 3 decretorum

    (According to Mantovani (1987) 219-222 form a group of works read together, but the exact arrangement cannot be settled)

    Unattached

    223. Gaius 3 regularum

    224. Gaius 1 regularum (ID, M; P, H)

    225. Paulus 1 de cognitionibus

    226. Paulus 1 de concurrentibus actionibus

    227. Paulus 1 de usuris

    (xix) SC Turpillianum group. S.

    1. 228. Paulus 1 ad SC Turpillianum

    2. 229. Marcianus 1 ad SC Turpillianum

      Unattached

    3. 230. Paulus 1 ad SC Libonianum

    4. 231. Paulus 1 ad SC Claudianum

    5. 232. Paulus 1 de poenis omnium legum (ID, M; S or P, H)

    6. 233. Paulus 1 de poenis paganorum

    7. 234. Paulus 1 ad regulam Catonianam (ID, M; S or P, H)

    8. 235. Paulus 1 de forma testamenti (ID, M; S or P, H)

    9. 236. Paulus 1 de inofficioso testamento (ID, M; S or P, H)

  8. (xx) tacita fideicommissa group. S.

    1. 237. Paulus 1 de tacitis fideicommissis (ID, M; P, H)

    2. 242. Gaius 1 de tacitis fideicommissis (p.157)

      Unattached

    3. 238. Paulus 1 de instrumenti significatione (ID, M; P, H)

    4. 241. Paulus 1 ad legem Falcidiam

  9. (xxi) SC Tertullianum group. S.

    1. 239. Paulus 1 ad SC Tertullianum

    2. 243. Gaius 1 ad SC Tertullianum

  10. (xxii) SC Orfitianum group. S.

    1. 240. Paulus 1 ad SC Orfitianum

    2. 244. Gaius 1 ad SC Orfitianum

      Unattached

    3. 245. Gaius 3 de manumissionibus

    4. 246. Gaius 3 de verborum obligationibus

  11. (xxiii) historical group. G.

    1. 247. Gaius 6 ad legem XII tabularum

    2. 248. Pomponius 1 enchiridii

    3. 249. Pomponius 2 enchiridii

      Unattached

    4. 250. Paulus 1 de iure libellorum

    5. 251. Paulus 1 de articulis liberalis causae

    6. 252. Paulus 1 de iuris et facti ignorantia

    7. 253. Paulus 1 de iure singulari

    8. 254. Paulus 1 de gradibus et adfinibus et nominibus eorum (ID, M; S or P, H)

    9. 255. Paulus 1 de officio adsessorum

  12. (xxiv) praefectus vigilum group. S.

    1. 256. Paulus 1 de officio praefecti vigilum

    2. 257. Ulpianus 1 de officio praefecti vigilum

  13. (xxv) praefectus urbi group. S.

    1. 258. Ulpianus 1 de officio praefecti urbi (ID, M; S or P, H)

    2. 259. Paulus 1 de officio praefecti urbi (ID, M; S or P, H)

      (BK 258 and 259 form a group but whether in the Sabinian or Papinian mass is uncertain)

      Unattached

    3. 260. Arcadius Charisius 1 de muneribus civilibus (ID, M; S or P, H)

    4. 261. Arcadius Charisius 1 de officio praefecti praetorio (ID, M; S or P, H)

    5. 262. Ulpianus 1 de officio quaestoris (ID, M; S or P, H)

    6. 262 bis. Scaevola 40 digestorum lib. 1-2 (P, M, H, O)

(p.158)

Edictal mass

  1. (xxvi) early edictal commentaries group. S.

    1. 95. Ulpianus 81 ad edictum lib. 1-25.

    2. 96. Paulus 78 ad edictum lib. 1-27

    3. 97. Paulus 23 brevium lib. 1-5

    4. 98. Gaius 30 ad edictum provinciale lib. 1-8, 19

    5. 99. Gaius ad edictum praetoris urbani

      Unattached

    6. 100. Callistratus 4 edicti monitorii lib. 1-2 (see BK 176)

  2. (xxvii) later edictal commentaries group. S.

    1. 101. Ulpianus 81 ad edictum lib. 56-81

    2. 102. Paulus 78 ad edictum lib. 53-78

    3. 103. Paulus 23 brevium lib. 16

    4. 104. Gaius 30 ad edictum provinciale lib. 21 fin.- 30

    5. 105. Gaius ad edictum praetoris urbani tit. de praediatoribus

    6. 106. Gaius ad edictum praetoris urbani tit. qui neque sequantur neque ducantur

    7. 107. Gaius ad edictum praetoris urbani tit. de re iudicata

  3. (xxviii) edict of the curule aediles group. S.

    1. 108. Ulpianus 2 ad edictum aedilium curulium

    2. 109. Paulus 2 ad edictum aedilium curulium

    3. 110. Gaius 2 ad edictum aedilium curulium

      Unattached

    4. 111. Papinianus 1 αστυνομικὸς (ID, M; P or Appendix, H)

  4. (xxix) transferred edictal commentaries group. S.

    1. 112. Ulpianus 81 ad edictum lib. 54-55 init.

    2. 113. Paulus 78 ad edictum lib. 50-51

    3. 114. Gaius 30 ad edictum provinciale lib. 20

    4. 115. Gaius ad edictum praetoris urbani de liberali causa

    5. 116. Ulpianus 81 ad edictum lib. 55 fin.

    6. 117. Paulus 78 ad edictum lib. 52

    7. 118. Gaius ad edictum provinciale lib. 21

    8. 119. Gaius ad edictum praetoris urbani tit. de publicanis

    9. 120. Ulpianus 81 ad edictum lib. 52 fin.- 53

    10. 121. Paulus 78 ad edictum lib. 48 fin.- 49

    11. 122. Gaius ad edictum provinciale lib. 19

    12. 123. Gaius ad edictum praetoris urbani tit. de operis novi nuntiatione, de damno infecto, de aquae pluviae arcendae (p.159)

  5. (xxx) commentaries ad Plautium group. S.

    1. 124. Paulus 18 ad Plautium lib. 1-14

    2. 125. Iavolenus 5 ad Plautium lib. 1

    3. 126. Pomponius 7 ad Plautium lib. 1

    4. 127. Iavolenus 5 ad Plautium lib. 2

    5. 128. Pomponius 7 ad Plautium lib. 2-3 (2, H)

    6. 129. Paulus 18 ad Plautium lib. 15-18

    7. 130. Iavolenus 5 ad Plautium lib. 3-5

    8. 131. Pomponius 7 ad Plautium lib. 4-7 (3-7, H)

    9. 132. Paulus 4 ad Vitellium (N, H)

    10. 133. Paulus 2 de iure fisci (N, H)

  6. (xxxi) Celsus-Marcellus digesta group. G.

    1. 134. Celsus 39 digestorum

    2. 135. Marcellus 31 digestorum

  7. (xxxii) Modestinus group. A.

    1. 136. Ulpianus 3 de officio consulis (N, H)

    2. 137. Modestinus 1 de manumissionibus

    3. 138. Modestinus 9 differentiarum

    4. 139. Modestinus 10 regularum

    5. 140. Modestinus 1 de ritu nuptiarum

    6. 141. Modestinus 1 de differentia dotis

    7. 142. Modestinus 6 excusationum

    8. 143. Ulpianus 1 de officio praetoris tutelaris

    9. 144. Ulpianus 1 excusationum

    10. 145. Modestinus 4 de praescriptionibus (non-existent, the sole text so inscribed coming from his pandectarum lib. 4, BK Ordo 149)

    11. 146. Modestinus 19 responsorum

    12. 147. Modestinus 1 de enucleatis casibus

    13. 148. Modestinus 1 de praescriptionibus

    14. 149. Modestinus 1 pandectarum

    15. 150. Modestinus 1 de heurematicis

    16. 151. Modestinus 1 de inofficioso testamento

  8. (xxxiii) Iavolenus group. A.

    1. 152. Iavolenus 15 ex Cassio

    2. 153. Iavolenus 14 epistularum

      Unattached

    3. 154. Pomponius 39 ad Quintum Mucium

    4. 155. Proculus 11 epistularum lib. 1-6

    5. 156. Pomponius 15 variarum lectionum (p.160)

    6. 157. Proculus 11 epistularum lib. 7-11

    7. 158. Callistratus 4 de iure fisci (ID, M)

    8. 159. Paulus 3 de censibus (ID, M; S or P, H)

    9. 160. Callistratus 6 de cognitionibus

    10. 161. Tertullianus 8 quaestionum

  9. (xxxiv) commentaries on lex Iulia et Papia group. S.

    1. 162. Ulpianus 20 ad legem Iuliam et Papiam

    2. 163. Paulus 10 ad legem Iuliam et Papiam

    3. 164. Terentius Clemens 20 ad legem Iuliam et Papiam

    4. 165. Gaius 15 ad legem Iuliam et Papiam

    5. 166. Mauricianus 6 ad legem Iuliam et Papiam

    6. 167. Macellus 6 ad legem Iuliam et Papiam

      Unattached

    7. 168. Macer 2 ad legem vicensimam hereditatis

    8. 169. Gaius 1 ad legem Glitiam (ID, M; P, H)

    9. 170. Paulus 1 ad legem Cinciam (ID, M; S or P, H)

  10. (xxxv) military law group. S.

    1. 171. Arrius Menander 4 de re militari

    2. 172. Tarrutienus Paternus 4 de re militari

      Unattached

    3. 173. Tertullianus 1 de castrensi peculio

    4. 174. Modestinus 4 de poenis

    5. 175. Licinius Rufinus 12 or 13 regularum (IA 12)

    6. 176. Callistratus 4 edicti monitorii (including lib. 1-2 from BK 100)

    7. 177. Papirius Iustus 20 constitionum

    8. 178. Aelius Gallus 1 de verborum quae ad ius pertinent significatione

    9. 179. Iulius Aquila 1 responsorum

Appendix

  1. 263. Paul 2 (6 IA) imperialium sententiarum in cognitionibus prolatarum (ID, M; App., H, O)

  2. 264. Quintus Mucius Scaevola 1 ορων (ID, M; App., H, O)

  3. 265. Labeo 10 posteriorum a Iavoleno epitomatorum lib. 2 fin.-10 (for earlier books see BK 93 bis)

  4. 265 bis. Iavolenus 10 posteriorum lib. 2 fin.–10 (for earlier books see BK 94) (p.161)

  5. 266. Proculus 3 ex posterioribus Labeonis

    (This work is non-existent, the sole text, inscribed IDEM, referring rather to 265 bis)

  6. 267. Scaevola 40 digestorum lib. 3-40

  7. 268. Labeo 8 πιθανων a Paulo epitomatorum

  8. 269. Pomponius 20 epistularum

  9. 270. Pomponius 5 de senatusconsultis

  10. 271. Scaevola 1 quaestionum publice tractatarum

  11. 272. Valens 7 actionum

    (This work is non-existent, the sole text so inscribed referring rather to BK 273)

  12. 273. Venuleius Saturninus 10 actionum

  13. 274. Venuleius Saturninus 6 de interdictis

  14. 275. Furius Anthianus 1 (5 IA) ad edictum (ID, M; App., H)