Jump to ContentJump to Main Navigation
Sacred Signs in Reformation ScotlandInterpreting Worship, 1488–1590$

Stephen Mark Holmes

Print publication date: 2015

Print ISBN-13: 9780198747901

Published to Oxford Scholarship Online: October 2015

DOI: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198747901.001.0001

Show Summary Details
Page of

PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2017. All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the licence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of a monograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: null; date: 25 February 2017

(p.214) (p.215) Appendix 1 Copies of the Rationale Examined

(p.214) (p.215) Appendix 1 Copies of the Rationale Examined

Source:
Sacred Signs in Reformation Scotland
Author(s):

Stephen Mark Holmes

Publisher:
Oxford University Press

Date

Repository

Call number

Pr.1

Provenance 2

Marg.

Marg. Type

14th c.

OBL

Lincoln Lat. 50

Eng.

Donated by John Southam 1437

Y

1, 6–10, 11, 19

14th c.

LLP

MS 68

Eng.

Llanthony 2da Priory OSA Glouc.

Y

1, 2, 3, 6–10, 19

late 14th c.

OBL

Laud Misc. 461

Eng.

fol. 217v note on the Scots1

Y

1, 3, 4, 8, 10

15th c.

OBL

Laud Misc. 311

Emp.

Y

1, 6, 7, 9, 19

1451 Vn

OBL

MS.Add.D.39

It.

Y

1, 6, 7, 8, 9, 12

1459 Mz

BNF

Velins-125

It.

OSB S. Gior. Mag. Venice 1461

Y

15, 16

1459 Mz

BNF

Velins-126

Fr.

priest, chaplain 1472; canon 1478

Y

2, 6, 17

1459 Mz

BNF

Velins-127

It.

priest 1462; OSA

Y

8 (questions), 11, 14, 15

1459 Mz

BL

C.14.e.6

[collection of Thos Grenville 19th c.]

Y

3

1459 Mz

OBL

Auct. 4.Q 1.3

N

19

1459 Mz

OAS

LR.5.l.1

Eng.

Bp James Goldwell 1465

Y

1, 4, 6, 7, 8, 10, 12

1463 Vn

OBL

MS. (canonici) Liturg. 361

It.

Y

19 (and 3 ‘nota’)

1470 St

OBL

MS.Laud Misc. 100

Sco.

‘Liber conventus de…’

Y

1, 3, 6–12, 14

1470 Ag

BNF

B-2

[marginalia dated 1504, 1512]

Y

6, 10.1/.2/.3, 11

1470 Ag

BL

I.C.5413

Emp.

O.Cart Buxheim

Y

3, 5, 6, 9, 14, 15

1470 Ag

OBL

Auct. 6 Q 1.3

Emp.

Altomünster Bridgettine nuns

Y

1, 3, 6, 7, 8, 10, 10.5

1470 Ag

GUL

Sp Coll BD12-a.9

Emp.

Bamberg OFM Obs.

N

1470 ag

OBL

Auct. 5 Q inf. 1.3

Emp.

Baumberg abbey OSA

Y

1, 10, 10.5, 11, 19

1473 Rm

BNF

B-3

Fr.

canon

Y

1

1473 Rm

BNF

B-4

N

1473 Rm

BNF

B-4 bis

Fr.

Y

3

1473 Rm

BL

IC.17290

It.

Nuns

Y

1, 3, 6, 7, 8, 10

1473 Rm

OBL

Auct. 1 Q 1.12

Y

1, 3, 6–8, 10, 10.3, 11, 12, 14

1473 Um

BL

IC.9115

Emp.

OSA hermits Munich

N

1473 Um

OBL

Auct. 5 Q 2.21

N

19

1475 Um

BNF

B-590

Emp.

Jesuits, Alsace

Y

2

1475 Um

BL

IC.9140

N

1475 Um

OBL

Auct. 1 Q 1.24

OFM Capuchins

N

1475 Cl

BNF

B-585

Emp.

OFM recollects Koblenz

N

1475 Cl

BL

IB.2990

N

1475 Cl

LLP

[ZZ]1475.3

Eng.

clergy; John Fox martyrologist

Y

1, 2, 6, 8, 10.1–5, 11, 14

1475 Pr

BNF

B-5

Fr.

priest?

Y

1, 2, 8, 10.3/.4, 12, 13

1475 Pr

BL

IB.39053

Fr.

canon

N

1475 Pr

OBL

Auct. Q sup. 2.2

Emp.

monk? near Würzburg?

Y

2, 7, 8, 14, 16

1476 Bs

BNF

B-581

N

1476 Bs

BNF

B-582

Fr.

O.Cist, Feuillants

Y

1, 6, 10, 18

1476 Bs

OBL

Inc.b.GS2.1

Y

6, 9

1476 Sp

BNF

B-584

Emp.

OSA Halle; OSB Brauweiler

Y

One—1

1476 Sp

OBL

Inc.d.G8.1

Y

3, 10, 10.2

1476 Sp?

BL

IB.8517

Y

11

1477 Rm

BNF

B-591

Y

1(questions), 8, 10, 15

1477 Rm

BNF

B-592

Y

1, 6, 7, 13, 14, 15, 16

1477 Rm

OBL

Inc.c.I2.1477.1

It.

friar

Y

1, 3, 6–11, 13

1477 Rm

GUL

Sp Coll BD7-b.15

Y

1, 5

1477 Bs

BL

IC.37024

It.

St Nicholas coll. church, Padua

Y

Few numbers in margins

147? Sb

BNF

B-6

(rubricated 1478)

N

147? Sb

BNF

B-7

Emp.

Basle. O.Cart

Y

3, 6, 10, 11, 14, 15

147? Sb

BNF

B-8

N

147? Sb

BNF

B-580

Fr.

O.Carm.

Y

Few

147? Sb

BNF

B-588

Fr.

canon

N

147? Sb

BL

IB.1044

Y

3

1478 Sb

BNF

B-583

Fr.

religious—parish church

Y

Few

147? Sb

OBL

Auct. 6 Q 1.4

Emp.

priest; OSA hermits Ramsau

Y

2, 6–12

147? Sb

OBL

Auct. 5 Q 4.11

Y

2, 6

147? Sb

ONC

BT1.91.5

Y

11, 14

1478 Vz

BNF

B-593

Sp.

N

1478 Vz

BL

IB.31812

Emp.

OSB St Paul’s abbey, Carinthia

N

1478 Vz

OBL

Auct. 1 Q 2.16

It.

monk? (‘Dom’)

Y

8, 10.2, 14

1478 Vz

OBL

Douce 296

Y

2, 4, 6, 10, 11, 14

1479 Sz

BNF

B-1466

Fr.

priest, curé; O.Praem.

Y

10, 12

1479 Sb

BL

IB.1048

Emp.

nuns, St Agnes, Trier.

N

1479 Sb

GUL

Sp Coll Bf71-a.4

Y

3, 6–10, 10.2

1479 ?

BNF

B-594

It.

Florence

Y

Italian tr. of dies irae

1479 Tr

BNF

B-595

It.

Y

1, 3, 8

1480 Vz

BNF

B-600

Fr.

canon; OSA

Y

1, 6, 7, 8

1480 Vz

OBL

Auct. 6 Q 3.37

Fr.

N

1480 Nm

BNF

B-597

Fr.

canon

N

1480 Nm

BNF

B-598

Emp.

OFM

N

1480 Nm

BL

IB.7200

Emp.

OFM

N

2, 11

1480 Nm

OBL

Auct. Q sup. 2.8

Emp.

Y

2, 11

1480 Bs

BL

IC.37101

Emp.

OFM

Y

1, 3, 11, 13

1481 Ly

BNF

B-1455

Fr.

priest

Y

10.5, 14

1481 Nm

BNF

B-9

Fr.

priests; religious

Y

8, 9, 10, 15

1481 Nm

BL

IB.7235

Emp.

N

1481 Nm

OCC

e.5.55

Y

2, 6, 10.5

1482 Vn

BL

IB.20889

It.

N

1482 Vn

CCCC

EP.G.14

Eng.

Abp Parker 1520; earlier marginalia

Y

1, 3, 6, 12, 18

1483 Sb

BL

IB.1936

Emp.

OSB abbey of Asbach, Bavaria

Y

few

1483 Sb

OBL

Broxb. 19.3

Emp.

Erfurt

Y

1, 2, 6, 8–10, 10.4, 10.5, 14

1484 Sb

BL

IB.1815

Emp.

religious, St George Freising

N

1484 Sb

LLP

L40.4.5 [ARC]

Eng.

Nat. Torperley (1564–1632)

Y

1, 2, 4, 6–11 (10.5)

1485 Vn

BL

IB.20550

priest?

Y

6, 7

1485 Vn

OBL

Auct. 2 Q 2.2 (1)

monastery

N

1485 Vn

OBL

Inc.c.I4.1485.1

Emp.

Mehrerau abbey OSB

Y

6, 7, 10, 10.3, 10.4

1485 Vn

OKE

Millard 39

Y

1, 6, 7, 8, 10, 10.4, 12, 14

1486 Sb

BNF

B-601

N

1486 Sb

BNF

B-602

OFM

Y

9, 10.2

1486 Sb

BL

IB.1852

Emp.

priest?

N

1486 Sb

OSJ

Cbd.b.3.u.s.12

Eng.

friar? ‘f. Thomas colman’

N

1486 Sb

SHL

Incunabula 88

Sco.

Duncan Shearer, Aberdeen cathedral

Y

2, 3, 6, 8–10

1487 Vn

BNF

B-1469

It.

OFM

N

1488 Bs

BNF

B-603

Emp.

OFM

Y

2, 8

1488 Bs

BL

IB.37605

Emp?

monastery

Y

10

1488 Sb

BL

IB.1889

Emp.

OFM Obs.

N

1488 Sb

AUL

Inc 10a

Sco?

[John Forbes c.1700]

Y

1, 4

1488 Sb

OBL

Auct. 3 Q 5.38

OFM (modern?)

N

1488 Ly

BNF

4°Z.Don 205 (23).

Fr.

OSB, Grand Prior of Cluny

Y

10.5

1491 Vn

BNF

B-1499

It.

priest?

Y

1

1491 Vn

BL

IB.22457

Y

3

1493 Sb

BNF

B-604

Emp.

OSA Halle; OSB Brauweiler

Y

few

1493 Sb

BL

IB.1913

Y

1493 Sb

BL

IB.1914

Emp.

OFM Obs. Gottingen

Y

10

1493 Sb

OBL

Auct. 3 Q 5.35

Emp.

priest?

Y

11

1494 Ly

BNF

B-2510

Fr.

priest; OFM

Y

2

1494 Ly

OMA

Arch.C.I.1.4

N

1494 Vn

BL

IB.23934

It.

date 1553 in marg.

Y

1, 6, 12

1494 Nm

BL

IB.7478

OFM

N

1494 Nm

OBL

Auct. Q sup. 1.9

N

1499 Ly

BNF

B-28981

Fr.

priest; OFM

Y

1, 2, 3, 7, 8

1499 Ly

BL

IB.41962

Eng.

‘Duke of Sussex’

Y

5, 8, 13, 15

1499 Vn

BNF

B-10

It.

religious

Y

1, 2, 3, 8, 10, 14

1499 Vn

BL

IB.23197

N

1500 Ly

BNF

B-2511

Fr.

priest? OSB, O.Cist. Feuillants

Y

6, 8, 9

1500 Ly

CUL

A*.5.31

Eng.

Laurence Banks (c.1600)

Y

2, 6, 7, 13, 15, 16, 18

1500 Ly

OBL

AA 150 Th.Seld.

Eng.

Valentine Davy, priest

Y

6, 7, 9, 13

1501 Sb

CUL

Adams.4.50.1

Emp?

German inscr. on f.e.p.

N

1503 Ly

CCCC

SP.51

Eng.

Abp Parker

N

1503 Pr

BL

C.48.g.8

Fr.

(French tr)

Y

2, few notes in French

1503 Pr

OBL

Douce O 180

Fr.

(French tr)

N

1504 Sa

BNF

B-1497

Sp.

Y

3, 14

1506 Ly

BL

C.77.d.17

Eng.

OSB (Burton); Abp Cranmer

Y

5, 8, 9, 10, 13, 15

1508 Ly

BNF

B-2512

Fr.

OSA

Y

6, 10

1508 Ly

BL

468.a.4

Eng.

Abp Cranmer

N

1508 Ly

OMA

m.17.6

Eng.

‘Sefton, howard, lyill’

Y

1, 2, 6–9, 10, 10.4, 11-13

1509 Hg

BNF

D-533 (2)

Emp.

Y

2

1509 Hg

GUL

Sp Coll K.T. f26

Emp.

Regensburg, religious

Y

1–3, 10, 10.3–5

1512 Ly

BL

860.l.5

Emp.

OSA Munich

N

1512 Ly

CUL

K*.10.50

Eng.

[Bp John Hacket 1670]

Y

Few

1512 Ly

OBL

Vet. E1 d.39

Fr.

N

1512 Ly

OCC

Hyp.O.25

Eng.

Y

1, 2, 4, 6, 7, 10.3–5, 11-13

1515 Ly

LLP

H1970.(D8) [**]

Eng.

marginalia in English

Y

2, 6, 8, 10.2, 14

1516 Ly

DUL

St Chad’s B3

N

1516 Ly

LLP

H1970.(D8)

Emp.

marginalia in German

Y

2, 4, 8, 10, 11

1518 Pr

BNF

B-27884

Fr.

N

1518 Ly

BL

7.a.8

Eng.

‘Thomas Wyllyams’

Y

1, 2, 8, 10.1

1519 Hg

BNF

B-604 (bis)

Emp.

St Nicholas in Bruwyke

Y

6, 12

1519 Hg

BL

468.b.21

Y

1, 6, 8, 10, 11

1519 Vn

OBL

D 3.4 Th

Y

9

1528 Ly

BNF

B-2513

Fr.

N

1528 Ly

BNF

B-2513 (bis)

Fr.

N

1531 Ly

ONC

BT1.130.12(2)

Eng.

purchased by New College in 16th c.

N

1535 Ly

BNF

B-3082

Fr.

OFM recollect

N

1540 Ly

BNF

B-1501

Fr.

Royal Library

N

1540 Vn

OBL

Vet. F1 e.250

It.

Y

6

1540 Vn

OBL

Vet. F1 e.18

Y

2, 3, 7, 8, 13, 14

1551 Ly

AUL

pi 264 Dur 1

Sco.

Bp William Gordon of Aberdeen

Y

2, 7, 10.1/.3, 13

1551 Ly

OWA

i6.1

Eng?

donation at fd. of Coll. in 1610

N

1551 Ly

GUL

Bk3-f.13

Sco.

Jas Strachan, canon of Aberdeen 1553

Y

1–3, 6, 8–10, 13

1551 Ly

LLP

H1970.(D8)

F. C. Eeles 20th c.

N

[19]

1560 Ly

SAL

AN.41

Sp.

Scots College, Madrid; ‘Gallego’

Y

1, 4, 6, 9, 10, 12

1561 Vn

BL

1221.g.29

N

1562 Ap

CUL

A*.7.7

Eng.

‘Jo Charde Gibs’

Y

4

1565 Ly

BL

843.d.14

Eng.

‘Lumley’

N

1565 Ly

CUL

F.156d.4.1

Pol?

Prince Roman Sanguszko, 19th c.

N

1565 Ly

NLS

BCL.B244

Scalan seminary, Scotland; Spain?

N

1568 Vn

BNF

B-28977

Y

2, 7, 12

1568 Vn

NLS

Oban.44

N

1568 Ly

BNF

B-7234

Fr.

Sorbonne University

N

1568 Ly

BNF

B-42283

Fr.

priest?

Y

Few. 10, 10.5

1570 Ap

CUL

G.2.71

old CUL marks

Y

2, 6, 11

1570 Ap

OBL

8° D 1 Th.

Eng.

N

1572 Vn

BNF

B-44406

Y

2, 8, 10

1574 Ly

BNF

B-7235

Fr.

OFM Cap.

N

1574 Ly

BNF

B-3505

Fr.

bishop

N

1574 Ly

BNF

B-3505 (bis)

Fr.

priests? university?

N

1581 Vn

NLS

CIM 338

N

(p.216) (p.217) (p.218) (p.219)

(p.220) Repositories

AUL

Aberdeen University Library

(2)

BL

London, British Library

(37)

BNF

Paris, La Bibliothèque nationale de France

(57)

CCCC

Cambridge, Corpus Christi College, Parker Library

(2)

CUL

Cambridge University Library

(6)

DUL

Durham University Library

(1)

GUL

Glasgow University Library

(5)

LLP

London, Lambeth Palace Library

(6)

NLS

Edinburgh, National Library of Scotland

(3)

OAS

Oxford, All Souls

(1)

OBL

Oxford, Bodleian Library

(35)

OCC

Oxford, Christ Church

(2)

OKE

Oxford, Keble College

(1)

OMA

Oxford, Magdalene College

(2)

ONC

Oxford, New College

(2)

OSJ

Oxford, St John’s College

(1)

OWA

Oxford, Wadham College

(1)

SAL

Salamanca, Real Colegio de Escoceses, Library

(1)

SHL

London, Senate House Library

(1)

Total Copies Examined 166

Including manuscripts (in italics) 7

(p.221) Place of Publication

Ag

Augsburg

Ap

Antwerp

Bs

Basle

Cl

Cologne

Hg

Haguenau

Ly

Lyon

Mz

Mainz

Nm

Nuremberg

Pr

Paris

Rm

Rome

Sa

Salamanca

Sz

Salzburg

Sp

Speyer

Sb

Strasbourg

St

St Andrews

Tr

Treviso

Um

Ulm

Vn

Venice

Vz

Vicenza

Provenance Areas

Emp.

Holy Roman Empire

(36)

Eng.

England

(23)

Fr.

France

(33)

It.

Italy

(16)

Pol.

Poland

(1)

Sco.

Scotland

(5)

Sp.

Spain

(3)

Provenance

Bishops and Cathedrals

7

Priests

22

[Secular clergy

29]

Benedictines (OSB)

9

Cistercian Feuillants

2

Carthusians (O.Cart.)

2

Augustinians (OSA)

9

Premonstratensians (O.Praem.)

1

Franciscans (OFM)

10

Reformed Franciscans

7

Carmelites (O.Carm.)

1

Bridgettines

1

Nuns

2

Unidentified religious

13

[Regular clergy

55]

Laity

4

Universities

7

(p.222) Copies With Marginalia

105 out of 166

63%

To 1477

34 out of 45

76%

1478–1485

26 out of 40

65%

1486–1509

27 out of 41

66%

1510–1581

18 out of 40

45%

Types of Marginalia and Marks

1

words from the text

(39)

as headings

2

underlining

(33)

3

manicules

(24)

4

marginal scriptural- and

(9)

cross-references

5

manuscript tables added to

(4)

the volume

Marginalia and marks in:

6

Book 1, on the Church

(36)

7

Books 2 and 3, on the clergy

(22)

and vestments

8

Book 4, on the mass

(34)

9

Book 5, on the office

(19)

10

Books 6 and 7, the liturgical

(42)

year:

10.1

Advent

[4]

10.2

Christmas

[6]

10.3

Lent

[8]

10.4

Easter

[8]

10.5

the triduum only

[9]

11

Book 8, calendar theory

(24)

and practice

Marginalia and marks on:

12

scriptural interpretation

(15)

13

reformation controversies

(13)

14

rites for the dead

(19)

15

liturgy

(10)

16

monasticism

(4)

17

miracles

(1)

18

images

(3)

19

corrections

(8)

Notes:

(1) Fol. 217v of Laud Misc. 461, containing Durandus’s section on the feast of St Andrew, has marginal notes at the foot of the page on the Scots together with an anti-Scottish poem of Ranulph Higden; the next page, 218r, has a history of the translation of the relics of St Andrew to St Andrews added at the foot of the page.