Losers' Consent
Elections and Democratic Legitimacy
Anderson, Christopher J. Department of Political Science, Syracuse University
Blais, André Department of Political Science, University of Montreal
Bowler, Shaun Department of Political Science, University of California, Riverside
Donovan, Todd Department of Political Science, Western Washington University
Listhaug, Ola Department of Sociology and Political Science, The Norwegian University of Science and Technology
Print publication date: 2005 (this edition)
Published to Oxford Scholarship Online: July 2005
Print ISBN-13: 978-0-19-927638-7
doi:10.1093/0199276382.003.0009
Christopher J. Anderson
André Blais
Shaun Bowler
Todd Donovan
Ola Listhaug
Examines the question of whether electoral losers will try to change the rules of the game or will stop participating in politics altogether. Expectations of future loss are likely to have an important impact when citizens are asked to consider replacing the current status quo institutions with another set. Examining proposed and enacted institutional reforms in a variety of areas and countries, we find that losers by and large are more likely to support changes in institutional practices. The findings help to demonstrate that losing is an important part of the motor that drives institutional change. While losing does not presage a disaster or an abrupt end to democratic practices, it does seem to be one of the first steps in the direction of change and reform. One of the difficulties facing the design of democratic institutions is to have institutions that make losers, but not permanent losers, and to allow current losers some reasonable chance of winning in future periods.
Keywords: election outcomes, elections, electoral rules, legitimacy, losers, political institutions, reform, system support, United States Electoral College, winners,
doi:10.1093/0199276382.003.0009
Quick Search Form

 
scroll up fast
scroll up
 
scroll down
scroll down fast
PART I THE WINNER–LOSER GAP
PART II UNDERSTANDING DIFFERENCES IN LOSERS' CONSENT