Subject: Political Science Book Title: Preservation Versus the People?
Preservation Versus the People?
Nature, Humanity, and Political Philosophy
Humphrey, Mathew
, Lecturer in Political Theory, University of Nottingham
Print publication date: 2002
Published to Oxford Scholarship Online: November 2003
Print ISBN-13: 978-0-19-924267-2
doi:10.1093/0199242674.001.0001
Abstract:
Environmental political philosophy has generally been framed around the differing axiologies of ecocentrism (nature-centred) and anthropocentric (human-centred) forms of ethics. This book seeks to challenge the political relevance of this philosophical dispute with respect to the problem of nature preservation as public policy. A detailed analysis of the philosophical underpinnings of both ecocentric and ‘ecological humanist’ positions shows that the ‘embedded humanism’ within ecocentric arguments offers an opportunity to move beyond the ecocentric-anthropocentric divide. Furthermore, a principle of ‘strong irreplaceability’ with regard to natural goods can provide the basis for a political argument for nature preservation that is compatible with both human-centred and nature-centred concerns.