Moore, Ray A. Professor of Asian History, Amherst College
Robinson, Donald L. Charles N. Clark Professor of Government, Smith College
Print publication date: 2002 (this edition)
Published to Oxford Scholarship Online:
Print ISBN-13: 978-0-19-515116-9
doi:10.1093/019515116X.003.0008
 

Ray A. Moore
Donald L. Robinson
Describes how Whitney pressured the Japanese government to accept the SCAP draft as the basis of a new constitution. Following talks with MacArthur and Whitney, the Shidehara cabinet accepted SCAP's demands and charged Matsumoto with preparing a draft for presentation to Government Section. Whitney and his staff expected the Japanese to submit essentially a translation of the SCAP draft, while Matsumoto believed he could determine the contents of the draft so long as he included the “fundamental principles” (the emperor as “symbol” and renunciation of war) mentioned by MacArthur to Shidehara. This misunderstanding caused a serious conflict when the two sides met to consider Matsumoto's March 2 draft.
Keywords: fundamental principles, Government Section, Matsumoto Jōji, Matsumoto's March 2 draft, SCAP's draft as a model, Shidehara-MacArthur talk, Yoshida Shigeru, Whitney
doi:10.1093/019515116X.003.0008
Quick Search Form
 
scroll up fast
scroll up
 
scroll down
scroll down fast
Fall 1945
Imposing the American Model
Transforming a Draft into a Constitution
Sequel