Rodriguez-Pereyra, Gonzalo
Fellow and Tutor in Philosophy, Hertford College,
Oxford
Print publication date: 2002 (this edition)
Published to Oxford Scholarship Online: January 2008
Print ISBN-13: 978-0-19-924377-8
doi:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199243778.003.0005
Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra
This
chapter explains in detail how Resemblance Nominalism answers the
Many
over One, what Resemblance Nominalism's theoretical apparatus is,
and how it can meet several objections. In a nutshell, Resemblance
Nominalism's answer to the
Many over One issue is that a particular
can have many properties by resembling different particulars (e.g., it is
F by resembling the
F-particulars,
G by resembling
the
G-particulars, and so on). The chapter also explains how this
idea can be extended to account for how a particular can be related in
different ways, as when
a is bigger than
b and to the right of
b. The issue of the identification of properties with classes is
also discussed. Several features of the notion of resemblance are discussed,
such as its objectivity, its primitiveness, the notion of degrees of
resemblance, the adicity of resemblance, and the transtemporality of
resemblance. The chapter also discusses the formal properties of
resemblance: its reflexivity, symmetry, and non-transitivity. It is shown
how these formal properties of resemblance, as well as the formal properties
of
exact resemblance, can be derived from more basic axioms of
Resemblance Nominalism. The chapter also includes an explanation of how
Resemblance Nominalism can accept facts or states of affairs, and discusses
several objections to Resemblance Nominalism.
Keywords: Armstrong,
axioms of resemblance,
adicity of resemblance,
classes,
degrees of resemblance,
facts,
paraphrase,
properties,
states of affairs,
transtemporality of resemblance
doi:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199243778.003.0005