Cogito?
Descartes and Thinking the World
Almog, Joseph
Professor Philosophy, UCLA
Print publication date: 2008 (this edition)
Published to Oxford Scholarship Online: May 2008
Print ISBN-13: 978-0-19-533771-6
doi:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195337716.003.0004
Joseph Almog
This chapter examines Descartes' view of another single thinking fact: thinking of God. Central to Descartes' account in Meditation III of thinking of God is an attempt to
prove from (i) this thinking fact (ii) a thought-
free fact about the cosmos, God's existence, or in the more telling gerund form, the fact of
God's existing. In
Meditations there are at least three separate proofs of this (purported) basic fact. In Meditation V, there is an attempted proof of
God's existing from God's essence (from his true and immutable “nature”), referred to as the
from His essence proof. In Meditation III, there are (at least) two other proofs. There is a proof
God's existing from
my (
JA's)
existing, referred to as the
from my existence proof. Finally, there is an attempted proof of
God's existing from this thinking-fact,
I think about God, referred to as the
from my thinking proof. The chapter focuses on one proof only: from my thinking of Him to His existence.
Keywords: Descartes,
thinking,
God,
Meditations,
proof,
reflection,
existence
doi:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195337716.003.0004